Seriously. Do not flush again. You’ll just add more water and risk overflow.

Use a flange plunger (the one with the extra rubber flap at the bottom). The flat-bottom “cup” plungers are for sinks. If all you have is a cup plunger, it’ll still work but takes more effort.

Push it into the drain hole at the bottom of the bowl at an angle so it seals over the opening. You want a tight seal, not just covering the poop—aim for the drain itself.

Here’s the step-by-step, no-nonsense guide.

How to Unclog a Toilet When There’s Still Poop in It (Yes, It Happens)

So the toilet’s clogged, the water level is high, and you’ve got… waste still in the bowl. Don’t panic. This is fixable, and you don’t need to stick your hand in anything gross.